Games Make Stories - Stories Make Games
Time for an example: I just finished re-reading one of my favorite novels, Dune, and that leaves me lusting for some Dune-style gameplay (luckily tonight we’re kicking off our Burning Wheel: Jihad game). So what kinds of games provide gameplay that matches my favorite parts of the Dune story?
Here are four games that are inspired by the Dune setting: Dune CCG, Fading Suns (and Fading Suns D20), Dune Board Game (Avalon Hill), and Burning Wheel: Jihad.
The Arakeen Dinner This is an awesome scene where multiple characters match wits and intrigues over dinner. Which games in the list have a social conflict mechanic?
The Strategy Briefing Early in Dune, Paul Atreides is invited to a strategy meeting with the Duke and his retainers in which they plan high level strategy for cementing their hold on the planet. Which games provide the ability to execute high level strategies?
The Duel with Feyd Rautha Blades! Blood! Treachery! Feints within feints! Which games have a well developed tactical combat mechanic?
The Traitor Yueh Dr. Yueh is one of the great traitors of fiction (IMHO). His motivations are complex, but his actions are perfectly consistent. Which games include backstabbing treachery?
Here’s how I measure the games up:
Here’s what I'm thinking:
Dune CCG Dune CCG has conflict modes for warfare, dueling, intrigue, and economics, which is a plus for providing a Dune experience. All of these are abstracted to a high level, so they don’t provide a sophisticated back and forth, which is a weakness when you compare the duel mechanic with, for example D20 tactical combat. Dune CCG handles many story aspects (such as Yueh’s treachery) as mechanics on specific cards, which is what you expect from a CCG, but not particular satisfying.
Fading Suns I once gave this game a glowing review, a fact that now embarrasses me. I loved it for what it was trying to achieve. Unfortunately, it failed. The social “conflict” mechanic is to roll against diplomacy or something. Strategy can be similarly handled. The D20 version includes social feats that are supposed to channel the characters into doing more interesting things, but they don’t really do this very effectively. Compared with the Artha mechanic in Burning Wheel, it’s anemic at best. The setting is great, but the system doesn’t do anything in particular to support it.
Avalon Hill Being a board game, its goals are more modest than an RPG's, and it achieves them quite well. I haven’t had a copy for about 20 years, so my memory may fail me. The game focuses on the strategic level. There is a specific treachery mechanic, which is important. As an additional benefit, an effort was made to use non-standard mechanics in such a way as to give that slightly alien feel that one gets from the Dune setting (at least I do).
Jihad Jihad’s the obvious winner here, having both a highly developed social conflict mechanic and tactical combat. Burning Wheel is very complex, but that’s not specifically a weakness in regards to emulating Dune. I edge D20 out in tactical combat here because Jihad explicitly includes superior mechanics for feints and other maneuvers that fit Dune style dueling well. And Jihad also includes an explicitly strategic level of conflict. Triple threat there! Jihad also has a character motivation mechanic.
The “problem” with all these games is that none of them gives me what I want in the area of treachery. Maybe what I’m looking for is a tactical treachery mechanic that is as sophisticated as D20 combat or the Burning Wheel battle of wits.
On the other hand, a game can only go so far in giving you the kind of story you’re looking for. For me, this works out into the humble realization that I need to abandon some of my more ambitious game designing activities and write some stories.